The staying power of this drugstore eyeliner is impressiveonce it's on, it'll stay put for a full 24 hours. A great option for anyone who wants to define their lashline and give their lashes a boost too. You can buy it on Amazon. Want something more fun than just black or brown? And drumroll please: the best drugstore eyeliner for tighlining is this Wet n Wild one. And no matter how much you build it up, the liner never gets flaky or cakey. Reviewers love the formula for it's creamy texture and long-lasting finish. Its composed of a vegan and cruelty-free formula that has been approved by PETA and comes in black and brown. We use cookies to personalize content and ads, provide social media features, and analyze our traffic. The formula is waterproof and comes in black and brown. Promise. I wear it every day and love it.". The brush tip makes all the difference in creating precise lines and points for winged liner. All products are independently selected, tested or recommended by our team of experts. After you successfully draw a wing, it will last all day and will not flake off. A good liquid eyeliner needs to tick a lot of boxes.Does it run when you cry at work? This bold eyeliner comes in black, mahogany, and navy and will go on smoothly without smudging or smearing. It comes in black, blue, and brown, and is great for those who wear contact lenses. If you want a more casual look perfect for an in-the-office day, this drugstore eyeliner will be the perfect one in your makeup kit. This is some of the best cat eye makeup to inspire all the face painters out there. THE REVIEW: "Finding cosmetics that are free of things you don't want on your skin can be challenging, says a tester, adding "this eyeliner accomplishes that really well.". While the color might not last very long, this drugstore eyeliner will leave you with a fantastic pop of color that will be perfect for any night on the town. Plus, the fact its always half-price at Chemist Warehouse sure doesnt hurt either. THE REVIEW: "For the price, this eyeliner cannot be beat," says a tester. This waterproof formula comes in a handful of neutral long-wearing colors such as Black, Black Violet, Brown, and Charcoal. This is the only liquid eyeliner I use regularly. Wait, Have You Tried Magnetic Eyelashes Yet? If You Arent Using These SPF Lip Balms, WYD? While it can get a bit smudgy, it comes in a handful of colors, including white, navy, and black. If you like a smudgy, smokey moment, a gel or cream eyeliner pencil with a built-in blending brush or sponge is your best bet. LOral Paris Flash Cat Eye is our number one pick for liquid eyeliner novices who need a helping hand with creating their wings. This is the best drugstore gel eyeliner that comes in eight dramatic shades, including Goal Digger Gold, Duchess Purple, Moss Boss Green, and Picante Red. They're also waterproof, and watch this clip to see how smudge-proof they are! This liner has a long stem that's super easy to maneuver (if you can draw a line with pen, you can use this one)plus the non-feathering formula is waterproof so you don't need to worry about your cat eye having a midday meltdown. So to make your next drugstore makeup shopping trip a success, Ive rounded up the 12 best eyeliners under $12 that should be on your radar. THE REVIEW: "You cannot go wrong with this for the price," says a tester, adding that "it's so easy to apply and the color staysplus you can use it like a million different ways too.". If you are more of a team gel liner, this is the best drugstore eyeliner for you. There are so many things to consider when purchasing eyeliner, but one weve never really worried about personally is price point. Choose it today and grab one from Ulta, or Amazon! Her work has also appeared on Girlfriend and beautyheaven. This is the best drugstore eyeliner if you would rather focus on your day ahead of you instead of sharpening a pencil. The formula features a Japanese technology of being long-lasting, smudge-proof and water-resistant, available in Black, Deep Brown, and Ultra Black. I like to use it as an eyeliner and a cream eyeshadow allover my lids too. I hope Pacifica keeps this one around for a long time!". Perfect for creating ultra-pigmented eyeliner looks, this Morphe pick is a no-brainer for nailing pro-level makeup looks in a cinch. "I typically do a simple cat eye for my everyday look using this without any primer and this stuff lasts all day.". Need a long-lasting drugstore eyeliner for long days at the office and longer, more fun nights partying? Waterproof and smudge-proof this overachiever can be worn for up to 24 hours after application. If you are looking for the best bang for your buck drugstore eyeliner, you have come to the right place. IDK about you, but I love a good gel eyeliner, like this drugstore option from L'Oreal Paris. Perfect for all-day bold looks. Its also hypoallergenic, great for sensitive eyes and contact lens wearers. Then youll love the Epic Ink Liner by NYX. They're also waterproof, and watch this clip to see how smudge-proof they are! Most gel liners have great color-payoff too, so you don't need to apply and reapply for a bold look. This vegan and cruelty-free formula goes on easily and dries fast to last the entire day. It has been known to flake off or wash off easily, but can create a very defined line with strong pigmentation so remember your primer. I highly recommend.". "I love that it comes with a smudger so you can get a lot of different looks with it. Pick this eyeliner up at Ulta, or Amazon today! Need some inspo before you start winging it with your liquid eyeliner? If you are trying to craft the perfect cat eye that will last for a long time, this intensely pigmented gel and brush combine for an easy-to-apply gel eyeliner. These are my go-to eyeliner pencils, as they're super pigmented and stay put for 16 hours. Eyeliners with super-fine precision tips should be your go-to if you like to tight-line, define your waterline, or are into thin, subtle lines. It has a super-rich pigment and smooth application, and it's available in more colors than you knew you needed. Use code SLASHEDBEAUTY for 25% off! The super-pigmented, long-lasting gel formula is hypoallergenic, derm-tested for safety, and infused with soothing and conditioning antioxidants like vitamin E. THE REVIEW: "I've used way more expensive eyeliners in the past that weren't nearly as good as this one," says a tester. So you're new to liquid eyeliner. When I want more color options, I reach for these-- they're available in mattes and metallics and offer vibrant color. While this creamy liner might be noted as greasy for some, it is composed of waterproof and smudge-proof ingredients and comes in Charcoal, Eggplant, Blackest Black, and Brown. It offers up to 16 hours of smudge-proof wear, while the built-in smudger is perfect for romantic diffused lines. With colors like Berry, Rose Gold, Go Green, Turquoise, Pink, and more, there is a shade for every personality. available in more colors than you knew you needed, waterproof water-resistant and/or transfer-proof, Comes with a built-in sponge for smudging and blending, Ultra-fine tip is delicate and prone to breakage, Some reviewers say the cap can come loose and unexpectedly pop off, Soft, creamy formula is great for the waterline and lashline, Waterproof formula won't smear or smudge for up to 24 hours, Some reviewers say it's difficult to remove, Gentle formula is safe for sensitive eyes, Some reviewers say the product runs out quickly, Made with clean, skin-friendly ingredients, Some reviewers say the formula is prone to smudging, Has bright, bold pigments that are smudge-proof, Some reviewers say it can be irritating to eyes, Ideal for creating thin, fine lines with ease, Some testers say the tip can get stick in the plastic casing, Not as highly-pigmented as some of the other eyeliners on the list, Helps conditions and strengthens your lashes with each use, Some reviewers say the formula isn't fully waterproof, Some reviewers say the pencil tip can be difficult to sharpen, Some reviewers say the formula is prone to creasing. Who knew you could get a primarily plant-based liquid eyeliner formula for less than a cool $20? This drugstore eyeliner can help create a chic, defined look. It may take a moment for the liquid liner to dry, but once it does, it leaves you with a professional look with up to 12 hours of wear time. Welcome! Grab this excellent product today from Ulta, or Amazon! to inspire all the face painters out there. It features a sharpener for a precise line, as well as a smudger for a less-opaque look. Pick it up at Ulta, or Amazon today! The Physicians Formula eyeliner goes on smoothly and defines, nourishes and conditions lashes as it traces your eye shape. If you continue to use this site we will assume that you are happy with it. This drugstore eyeliner has been known to flake off, but when it stays, it creates a great definition look that makes your eyes bold and beautiful. The 12 Best Eyeliner Pencils of All Damn Time, Hi, Your Oily Skin Needs One of These Primers ASAP, 12 Best Drugstore Eyeliners That Are Cheap, Affordable, and *Excellent*, Maybelline New York TattooStudio Smokey Gel Pencil Eyeliner, The Lip Bar Straight Outta Patience Eyeliner, Physicians Formula Ultra-Fine Liquid Eyeliner Black, L'Oreal Paris Cosmetics Infallible Pro-Last Eyeliner, NYX Professional Makeup Makeup Jumbo Eye Pencil. Fall in love with this long-lasting, top gel liner that you can purchase at Ulta, or Amazon. "There's no dragging and no skippingjust smooth color payoff. This drugstore eyeliner is top of the line for those of you who love the drama of the classic cat eye. Grab it from Ulta, or Amazon today! Fans love the deep, dark pigment that goes on easily with a precise tip. But this non-smudgeable offering comes equipped with an ultra fine tip thats not too long in the tail, allowing for a bit more precision when it comes time to applying those particularly tricky bits. Plus the pigments are fast drying, so once they're on they'll quickly set to a stunning, smudge-proof finish. The Glowsly editors independently test and choose the best products. Clean beauty lovers, this drugstore eyeliner from Honest Beauty is for you. "Try this and you'll never waste your money on more expensive brands," says another tester. When I want more color options, I reach for these-- they're available in mattes and metallics and offer vibrant color. Definitely one to keep on hand for those particularly tricky eyeliner looks that you want to last through the night. The formula stays put, it's easy to apply, and offers a rich black shade that goes on evenly. Customise your wings with this precision liquid eyeliner, which can turn out fine lines as skinny as 0.01mm or adjusted to provide a slightly thicker 2.00mm line. Drugstore makeup brandsfrom icons like Maybelline and CoverGirl to clean and vegan makeup brands Pacificamake some truly excellent eyeliners for a literal fraction of the price of the prestige brands. It is composed of a formula that will last 16 hours straight but be wary that it might use up fast. A surefire winner for when youre in a rush. Forget the fact that this stuff is literally only $3 (hard, we know) and join us in reveling in its truly classic formula. While it may not last very long and might flake off, this eyeliner is great for quick touch-ups. With a smudge-proof and waterproof formula, this is the best drugstore waterproof eyeliner around. Will it end up making best friends with your eyelids and smudge halfway through the day? With a cruelty-free and vegan formula, you dont have to worry about breaking the bank or harming the environment. Purchase it from Ulta, or Amazon! Want the best drugstore eyeliner that can go on thin or thick depending on your outfit or mood? THE REVIEW: "I have really struggled to find a more natural eyeliner that stays put on my oily lids but I'm happy to say I think I've found it! While it has been known to dry out too fast, this drugstore eyeliner is the well-rounded micro-liner for all of your makeup needs. The applicator makes perfect lines and the formula lasts for hours too. Lauren Balsamo is deputy beauty director at Cosmopolitan, where she writes, edits, and produces all types of beauty contentfrom product reviews to personal essays and trend reports. The Milani eyeliner is a favorite among beauty lovers both because it wont break the bank and because its pigmentation is on point. This drugstore eyeliner can be purchased from Ulta, or Amazon. If you prefer a liquid eyeliner that has a separate brush instead of a screw top or attached felt tip, then this is the best drugstore eyeliner for you. This liquid eyeliner is waterproof and will create a smooth line that will last all day but can turn runny if not shaken properly.