I found that I had to really rub at my eyes, and because I cringe at the idea of pinching my lashes with the wipes and wiggling the product off, I ended up sleeping with my mascara on that night. Instead, they're designed to wipe away the day's cosmetics with a single swipe, making them super convenientespecially for people who can't be bothered to put a little extra effort into their skincare routines. When you visit this site, it may store or retrieve information on your browser, mostly in the form of cookies. But Dr Tijion Esho, founder of the Esho Clinic, has posted to social media to show us exactly why we shouldnt be using makeup wipes to remove our foundation. 2022 BuzzFeed, Inc. All rights reserved. Carol Goodrich, director of global media relations for Neutrogena's parent company, Johnson & Johnson, provided the following statement in response to Allure's inquiry for this story: "We are deeply concerned about recent Neutrogena Makeup Remover Wipes complaints and ask that if consumers experience an adverse reaction, please call us at 1-800-582-4048 or send us a DM @Neutrogena immediately as we gather more details and get answers. As Dr. Esho highlighted, the makeup remover wipe was completely useless in removing all the makeup from the orange, showing that makeup wipes dont actually remove all dirt and grime from our skin. Eye makeup is notoriously stubborn and difficult to remove, so you need a good, safe makeup remover in your arsenal. When I woke up and took a peek in the mirror, I was so disappointed. Your makeup removal regimen may never be the same. All rights reserved. Makeup wipes are inherently harsh on your skin, because the amount of pressure required to remove your makeupespecially mascara and eyelineris already way too irritating, says Gohara. If you have the choice between using the wipe or going to the sink, go to the sink, Sangha said. These are sometimes formaldehyde-releasing chemicals and parabens. Your California Privacy Rights. If you need help purchasing a product directly from Allure, go to our FAQ. They just suck. Theres that residue thats left on the skin still, she said. They are great for a quick cleanse when one is too tired to cleanse with water as well as in situations where rinse-off cleansing is difficult, such as when camping, exercising, traveling or in other transient environments, he said. On day 15, I breathed a huge sigh of relief and reacquainted myself with my forever-faveEve Lom Cleanser($80). But if theyre leaving a sticky or tacky film on your face, what thats doing is really just attracting germs to your face and acting like a slime, essentially, to attract pollutants to the face.. You should definitely buy. Are they leaving us with a squeaky-clean face, or depositing more harmful chemicals in our skin? This content can also be viewed on the site it originates from. If they are safe and gentle enough for a baby, they should be fine for a teenager or woman. Someone else shared how they were so surprised to learn that the makeup wipes are virtually useless and hope to see more educational videos. In high concentrations, formaldehyde and parabens are considered toxic, and some, if used often enough, may also clog your pores, even if you are not exposing yourself to high amounts of these chemicals. It does not necessarily mean there is a 'bad batch,' although that certainly could be the case, but this would be [rarer].". Makeup wipes have certain inherent issues, Kraffert agreed. 9 Jelly Cleanser, Rachel is a board-certified dermatologist and Assistant Clinical Professor at Mount Sinai Hospital Department of Dermatology. The Garnier Micellar Cleansing Water is probably the BEST makeup removing product that you can possibly find at this price range, I mean, its just for 114! Another preservative to look out for, he said, is iodopropynyl butylcarbamate, which should not be inhaled. On the flip side, he said, phenoxyethanol is a safe and effective preservative.. She has contributed to Byrdie, as well as Harpers Bazaar, Marie Claire, Allure, Vogue, and the New York Times, and more. However, a lot of makeup products are waterproof or oil-soluble, and micellar water cannot break these down or loosen it all away from the skin. Lindsey Metrus is the associate general manager at Byrdie and has been with the brand since 2015. There are also wipes made for women, sometimes referred to as feminine hygiene wipes but theres nothing wrong with using baby wipes. The Best K-Beauty Skin-Care Products of 2018, 15 Face Washes That Work Wonders on Oily Skin. Dermatologist approved. . Part of HuffPost Style & Beauty. Theyre wetter than most wipes, which makes them glide really nicely and feel refreshing and prevents yucky pilling. Wipes have come a long way from even two years ago. However, she said, they shouldnt replace cleanser because they dont thoroughly clean your skin. Simply so Can you use makeup wipes as feminine wipes? If you have sensitive skin, this ingredient might irritate your skin. Then there are the added fragrances, which can also be problematic to sensitive skin and cause allergic reactions; and alcohol, which is extremely drying and can cause irritation and stinging. Makeup remover wipes are another item you need to watch out for. 7 Alternative Uses For Makeup Remover Wipes. User Agreement and Privacy Policy and Cookie Statement and What is your skincare routine? Allure may earn a portion of sales from products that are purchased through our site as part of our Affiliate Partnerships with That's because, unlike traditional cleansers, they don't require additional lathering and rinsing to rid the skin of built-up makeup, dirt, and debris. Makeup wipes are not formulated to actually clean your skin. While makeup wipes might seem like a godsend theyre quick and easy to use, which is great for low-maintenance folks and frequent travelers it turns out they could be doing more harm than good when it comes to keeping skin healthy. In other words, I'll stick with my fancy cleanser from now on, thanks. Dr. Esho coated the oranges skin in foundation and then used a makeup wipe to clean off the foundation, as the fruits peel mimics our own skins pores. Hirons was quite adamant that their only use is for fannies, festivals and flights, and have no business being on our faces as part of a skincare routine. Of course, sometimes using a makeup wipe is a necessity, like when you are stuck camping without potable water facilities, or if you hit the gym on-the-go and cant make it to the shower. The first night of using the wipe, I actually thought to myself that it might not be so bad. Makeup wipes are single-use cloths soaked with facial cleanser and/or makeup remover to rid skin of the day's beauty products, not to mention any remnants of dirt or debris. Makeup wipes are said to be the lazy girl's best beauty friend. MakeUp Eraser is great for ALL skin types because we dont use irritating chemicals JUST WATER! A post shared by Dr Esho MBChB MRCS MRCGP (@drtijionesho), So many people were shocked by the video, and there were many who commented on it. Let us know! Our editorial team shares the best beauty, makeup and lifestyle tutorials. "DO NOT USE these make up wipes Alyssa has been using them for months but yesterday opened a brand new pack to use and This Happened!!" Tunde Oyeneyin Says This Skincare Product Is "Very Slept On", Duckie Thot Uses This Ultra-Hydrating Night Cream to Maintain Her Supermodel Glow, Neutrogena's Ultra Gentle Hydrating Cleanser Calms Sensitive Skin, Hailey Biebers Trick for the Juiciest Skin Ever Is 100% Free, I Tried the Sustainable Makeup Remover Every Top MUA Is Obsessed With, "Literally, Everyone Needs It": Benny Drama on the $32 Sunscreen He Can't Live Without, How Alicia Keys's Break From Makeup Inspired Her Current Skincare Routine, This $350 Facial Made My Entire Face Scab Over (but Now I'm Glowing), The Best Face Washcloths for a Clean Start (and End) to Your Day, What to Expect the First Time You Get a Facial, Fresh's Soy Face Cleanser Calmed My Sensitive, Dry Skin, Pixi's Double Cleanse Leaves Skin Refreshed and Hydrated, Reviewed: Drunk Elephant's Lala Retro Cream, 10 Skincare Secrets Models Know (That You Don't), I Tried Australia's Rationale SkincareHere's Why I'll Never Stop, Reviewed: Drunk Elephant's Beste No. Yes: You can totally use (certain brands of) vaginal wipes as face wipes. Due to the need to apply concentrated surfactants and emulsifiers for best results, they can be drying and irritating.. There have been plenty of times when weve been tired and just wanted to go to bed, so rather than do a full routine, well reach for the makeup wipes. Likewise, Is micellar water better than makeup wipes? If you purchase a product found through our links, Sunday Edit may earn an affiliate commission. Certain ingredients, namely things like aloe, panthenol and glycerin, can provide some benefit to those with sensitive or dry skin, as theyre known to be soothing and moisturizing, Sangha added. In the post, a woman named Jaimie Potts laments what she says a very popular drugstore beauty product, Neutrogena Makeup Remover Cleansing Towelettes, allegedly did to her daughter's skin. A wipe every day definitely won't keep the breakouts away. In an episode of This Morning, Hirons said that its a misconception that they somehow work faster, pointing out that they do not work any faster than any other product. When you use makeup remover wipes, residue is left behind on your skin. Finally, by day 14, I'd had it. Some ingredients in a natural type of wipe are aloe vera leaf juice, willow bark extract, coconut oil, fruit extracts, cucumber extract, witch hazel and sugar cane. However, most dermatologists agree that those who suffer from skin flare-ups from eczema or rosacea should try to avoid them altogether, as the preservatives and irritants in wipes can cause the conditions to flare-up. As is the case with many skin care products, different formulas work better on different skin types. We all know that skincare is important. "We went on their website and TONS of reviews of the same reaction! In short, yes! You should follow up your face wipe with a gentle cleanser to help lift makeup and oil from your skin. In truth, at least seven varieties of Neutrogena makeup-removing wipes and towelettes may cause itching, burning, dryness, peeling, redness and inflammation, among other harmful reactions, and are decidedly not safe and effective for all skin types, the 41-page lawsuit claims. Do Neutrogena makeup Remover wipes work? Have you ever realized that you need to take a shower, but either had no shower available, or time to take one? issues like dryness, sensitivity, irritation or allergic reactions, Neutrogena Makeup Remover cleansing towelettes. We use cookies to ensure that you have the best experience on our site. What Are Blackheads Made Of, and WTF Comes Out When You Extract Them? No rubbing or tugging necessary. The author of the bestselling book, Skin Care, aesthetician Caroline Hirons, has also been an advocate for ditching the wipes. Dr. Esho isnt the only skincare expert to believe that makeup wipes have no place in our homes. Since wipes arent totally effective at getting rid of excess oil, using them regularly could lead to clogged pores, which could lead to breakouts. So with that, I closed up the package of makeup wipes and hid them deep in the back of my vanity, swearing only to open them again when my makeup wipe-loving friends pay me a visit. "In regard to the Neutrogena wipes, it's difficult to tell from the photo whether these were hives or eczema. In her experience, Sangha has noticed more acne breakouts in her patients that use face wipes exclusively to clean their skin. God, grant me the serenity to accept the things I cannot change. Unfortunately, on those nights, we either forget to cleanse off our makeupaltogether or resort to makeup wipes to remove the grime from our faces. Gently wipe face with towelette, removing dirt and all traces of face and eye makeup. Dr. Esho used an orange to demonstrate his point and it was quite shocking. "To help figure out which chemical someone may be allergic to, dermatologists can perform patch testing, which is a form of allergy testing," Marchbein advises. My skin was starting to break out like crazy, and I felt like a total masochist. Dispose of towelette in trash receptacle (do not flush). However, ever since the post went viral (it's been shared more than 150,000 times since May 2), many more people have left reviews stating they experienced a similar redness, puffiness, and itching. 2022 Cond Nast. Michelle Regalado is a seasoned editor, fact-checker, and content strategist with expertise in women's lifestyle news. The Garnier SkinActive Waterproof Micellar Cleansing Water is our top pick because it is a gentle but powerful one-step eye makeup remover that removes even the heaviest eye makeup easily. I couldn't help itI had events coming up and big weekend plans and needed to banish these blemishes fast. Not to mention they are so dry. Dr. Esho is right, you cant skimp on the skincare. Most makeup wipes ring up between $7 and $10; however, there are some pricy options, like Koh Gen Do's Cleansing Spa Water Cloths ($59) that well surpass that. Face wipes can be helpful for some, she said, especially if your alternative is not cleaning your face at all. Learn more here. I also chose to use a cult-favorite brandin the sensitive skin variation so the alcohol from the wipes wouldn't negatively affect my skin, thus throwing off the study. A year after opening its doors, the Allure Store is hosting its first-ever retail collaboration. Sign up for the Sunday Edit newsletter to stay in-the-know on all things skincare and beyond. My friends use them, friends of friends use them, my family uses them, and Olivia Holt told usshe swears by them. I realize I'm being hyperbolic, but truly, if I could go back in time and un-pitch the story, I might consider it. Your face might look makeup free when youre done, but these wipes dont actually cleanse your skin and tend to leave behind a residue that isnt doing your skin any favors.