Contains alcohol, which can be drying in the mouth. Please dont get this stuff. If you have trouble brushing daily, are especially prone to cavities, and/or have sensitive teeth, this stuff could be very helpful to you. Unlike some American brands that do this, theirs are helpfully color-coded so that you can immediately tell on sight if youre getting the woo or non-woo type. The mint flavor is lighter in those lines. Wtf is that? Its working really well for my spouses horrifically neglected and sensitive teeth. 2-Pack (Packaging May Vary), MOON Whitening Anticavity Toothpaste with Fluoride, Fresh Mint Flavor for Clean Breath, Tom's of Maine Fluoride-Free Propolis & Myrrh Natural Toothpaste, Fennel, 5.5 oz. Any thoughts on toothpastes with the Japanese N-Ha? I did find and try this one, though, and I like it. It feels kind of gritty and doesnt foam up. Required fields are marked *. The toothpastes you and I want, those holy-grail the white-whale varieties: Not-Primarily-Mint Non-Cinnamon Toothpastes with Fluoride for Adults, tested and reviewed for your edification. Sexual Desire, There Are Good Reasons to Not Date a Muslim Man, It's Cruel for an Atheist to Pray with Their Dying Mother, LGBT Muslims: Past & Present Realities, Not "An Oxymoron", Arranged Marriage Culture: You Know Even Less Than You Think. Thanks for this! Its runny, but a little bit goes a very long way. These ingredients are newer than fluoride and are still undergoing long term studies, but have been FDA approved. Turns out that the one good thing I can say about it is that its not very minty. Then, they were all discontinued. Eli has been an active participant in atheist organizations and events in and around Orange County, CA since 2007, and on the national stage since 2011. Thank you. Since its been discontinued I cant find anything comparable. The ones that tend to make it to US sellers, alas, tend to be the fluoride-free ones, imported for woo reasons. My latest stuck-at-home low-stakes project is finding a good non-mint toothpaste with fluoride. Its honestly very cathartic to see someone else wanting toothpaste that isnt mint and has fluoride. You definitely want to use the amount you actually need rather than what looks good in ads when youre spending this much money, time, and effort on a basic daily product. It left my teeth feeling a little odd, but again, not horrible. The thin formula doesnt foam up very much nor does it do a great job of cleaning. Free from artificial sweeteners and flavors. The extreme flavor of mint toothpaste makes me balk at brushing; what if I want to eat or drink or sleep not long afterwards? Finding Colgate Active Lemon & Salt Healthy White Toothpaste sent me down a bit of a non-US toothpaste rabbit-hole. It did an average job of cleaning, but not of freshening. Its not all talk, either. Ive been using Boka. It is my top overall pick regardless. Theres also, Once a day, I floss, then brush with a circular. The n-ha is very interesting maybe time for a change. I can touch ice cream to my teeth for the first time ever! Mint sometimes is a sensory nightmare for me, so Ill avoid it especially when Im already stressed out. Biotene mouthwash and the store brand knock-offs is really gentle and doesnt taste strongly of mint. I got the citrus mouthwash, too. Now Im in the same situation for mouthwash. It tastes very much like fennel. There was a luxe Japanese brand for a minute that sold no fewer than 28 fancy varieties. Whilst ingredients like xylitol have a small anti-cavity effect, it would not be enough to be remineralizing in the same way as fluoride. It looks like Im very much not alone! My teeth are definitely less sensitive now. Himalaya Botanique Complete Care Whitening Toothpaste, Simply Mint, for a Clean Mouth, Whiter Teeth and Fresh Breath, 5.29 oz, 4 Pack, Boka Lemon Lavender Natural Toothpaste, Nano-Hydroxyapatite for Remineralizing, Sensitivity and Whitening, Fluoride-Free, Dentist Recommended for Kids and Adults, Made in USA, 4oz (Pack of 1). I did a search for toothpaste that is not mint and your post was top of the list (well, after several toothpaste ads). Just found out Im allergic to both Cinnamon and mint so its great to find ones that arent going to blister my mouth. I generally avoid whitening products because I care about the long-term integrity of my dental enamel more than I do about having a perfectly-white smile. So. I tried this toothpaste anyway. If I get fancy toothpaste, I dont want to replace its taste with another one afterwards. At a whopping $15 per small-ish tube, though? I wont be using it again. After viewing product detail pages, look here to find an easy way to navigate back to pages you are interested in. As far as the taste goes, its as mild as it comes, barely having any flavor at all, which rather disappointed my citrus hopes. I crowd-sourced and researched and asked around and dug into it, even trying out some of the options. Its harmful as heck, especially now that people are using it as toothpaste. If you want a charcoal toothpaste, you probably dont care about science and therefore would be indifferent at best to the presence of fluoride. It has slightly less fluoride, but thats unlikely to cause much of an issue. Alas, these niche brands make a point of not including fluoride to their toothpastes. Yet I know that Im not the only adult chasing that not-having-my-mouth-burned high. Caveat about my reviews: My oral care habits and preferences might not match yours. One of my friends suggested using whatever hippie toothpaste you want, then adding a fluoride rinse at the end. BLESS YOU FOR THIS LIST. For occasional use, Im not worried about fluoride or whatever, I just want my mouth to get generally clean. One example of is, Arm and Hammer. The texture is a little runnier and grittier than standard toothpastes, but its not bad. Ive also added my review of Kingfisher Fennel and Toms of Maine Strawberry Fluoride rinse. ), Crest Kid's Cavity Protection Fluoride Toothpaste, Strawberry Rush, 3 Count, Dr. Sheffields Certified Natural Toothpaste (Strawberry Banana) - Great Tasting, Fluoride Free Toothpaste/Freshen Your Breath, Whiten Your Teeth, Reduce Plaque (2-Pack), Tom's of Maine Whole Care Natural Toothpaste with Fluoride, Cinnamon Clove, 4.0 oz. Its relatively high rating on both the Target and Hello sites absolutely flabbergasts me. While there definitely seems like theres something to n-ha for sensitive teeth, I dont know if basing toothpaste use on the positive or neutral dental reputation of Japan would be that useful a metric. (just spent a stupid amount of money on toothpastes). Ive added info about n-ha to the Carifree description. Meanwhile, their very lack of fluoride is a selling point for the aforementioned hippie toothpastes. As for the taste? I am a little nervous about not using a fluoride paste, though. If non-fluoride is what you are looking for I have these covered in, Avoid mint flavors (but may still contain traces of mint). The seller looked reputable Ill try to remember to report back! My reasons were: Its available at Target, which has a good return policy. Could have a stronger fluoride concentration. and pro-social. A non-mint fluoride free toothpaste that contains no fluoride and which does contain an alternative remineralizing agent. I also dont want to add to the market for fluoride-free toothpaste. The Orbit is a diverse collective of atheist and nonreligious bloggers committed to social justice, within and outside the secular community. If you like that kind of thing, though, theres nothing wrong with using kids toothpaste as an adult. On top of that, its made with several acidic fruit juices, which makes me question how healthy it is for brushing adult teeth. Ive used Kingfisher fennel with fluoride for 30 odd years now & have no teeth issues. There Ill be, feeling all sleepy, until I brush my teeth. Hmm. Easily available in supermarkets and drugstores. Just be sure its not the toddler/starter kind, which has no fluoride. So long, in fact, that I straight-up got distracted and forgot to brush the next day. 2-Pack (Packaging May Vary), Tom's of Maine Fluoride-Free Rapid Relief Sensitive Toothpaste, Fresh Mint, 4 oz. Some (but not all) ingredients are organic, depending on the paste. I love this post. Your email address will not be published. The Carifree I mentioned is an n-ha toothpaste that also has flouride. Ill update with my impressions if I ever succumb to that expensive temptation. 3-Pack (Packaging May Vary), Red Seal Lemon Toothpaste for Homeopaths, Homeopathic Friendly Mint Free, Fluoride Free, No SLS, Fresh Citrus Flavor Refreshing Natural Lemon Flavored Toothpaste, No Mint Flavor 3.5oz, FREE Shipping on orders over $25 shipped by Amazon, Auromere Ayurvedic Herbal Toothpaste, Mint Free - Vegan, Natural, Non GMO, Fluoride Free, Gluten Free, with Neem & Peelu (4.16 oz), 1 Pack, Auromere Ayurvedic Herbal Toothpaste, Mint Free - Vegan, Natural, Non GMO, Fluoride Free, Gluten Free, with Neem & Peelu (4.16 oz), 4 Pack, Arm & Hammer Advance White Toothpaste, Clean Mint Flavor, Stain Defense Technology, 6.0oz (4-Pack), Aquafresh Cavity Protection Fluoride Toothpaste for healthy gums, Mint, 5.6 Ounce (Pack of 1), Aquafresh Extreme Clean, Whitening Action, Fluoride Toothpaste for Cavity Protection, Twinpack, 11.2 Ounce (Pack of 1), Himalaya Complete Care Toothpaste, Fluoride Free to Reduce Plaque & Brighten Teeth, 6.17 oz, Colgate Whitening Toothpaste for Sensitive Teeth, Enamel Repair and Cavity Protection, Fresh Mint Gel, 6 Oz, Pack of 3, when you subscribe, Orajel Kids Paw Patrol Anti-Cavity Fluoride Toothpaste, Natural Fruity Bubble Flavor, 4.2oz Tube, Colgate Total Teeth Whitening Toothpaste, 10 Benefits Including Sensitivity Relief and Whitening, 4.8 oz ( Pack of 4 ), Colgate Anticavity Kids Toothpaste with Fluoride for Ages 2+, Watermelon Burst Flavor - 4.6 Ounce. They all seem to be woo branded. 10% of company profits each year donated to charity. Having nice-tasting toothpaste or even just not painfully-tingly toothpaste means brushing more regularly. Im still on the hunt! Free from animal ingredients and they do not test on animals. Its runnier than regular toothpaste and looks pretty dark. Why are there so few options without mint? We get it at Costco. This stuff comes in packaging so chic that the tubes and vials and tubs rival the fanciness of the very skincare that, I suspect, led the social media sites to show me the ads in the first place. The ACT Cinnamon I use is slowly disappearing and becoming harder to find. Japan is a relatively racially homogenous country and unfortunately, a lot of teeth/dental health comes down to genetics. Thanks for the recommendations, I will try the CTx4 gel until (fingers crossed) Delicious Teeth are back in business. I am quite amused to have discovered there are in fact others like me who thought mint burning was a natural thing. I just ordered a package of the Bonabits apple-rose flavor from ebay. Im 100% pro-fluoride but really dont like mint. By happenstance, I did end up trying the fluoride-free toothpaste followed by a fluoride rinse method. I dont use mouthwash very often, maybe once a month. I went with it because its very common in Japan and the Japanese arent known for having problem teeth. Its not even that hard to find, you just have to know what youre looking for. Mint toothpaste obsession isnt universal, it turns out. Its from a brand people seem to love. medication that would be affected by exposure to activated charcoal, CariFree CTx3 Fluoride Rinse Anti-Cavity (Citrus), Toms of Maine Silly Strawberry (childrens), Hello Oral Care Kids Fluoride Rinse, Natural Wild Strawberry, Listerine Nightly Reset Mouthwash in Twilight Mint, https://bitetoothpastebits.com/blogs/blog/the-f-word-3-reasons-why-our-bits-are-fluoride-free. Your list saved me, I appreciate you so much. The packaging tends to be darker and include a moon or bed logo. Other leads for mint toothpaste that doesnt overwhelm: Lots of toothpastes intended for kids are fluoridated and come in fun flavors. Earnings Disclosure & Privacy Policy, The Best Waterpik / Water Flosser For Braces 2022, The Best Toothbrush For Braces, Electric & Manual, mint is not always listed in the ingredients, I dont normally recommend fluoride free toothpaste, Supersmile Professional Teeth Whitening Toothpaste, Himalaya Botanique Complete Care Toothpaste, Jason Healthy Mouth Tartar Control Anti-Cavity Toothpaste, Kiss My Face Kids Berry Smart Gel With Fluoride, Toms of Maine Antiplaque and Whitening fluoride free toothpaste, Toms of Maine Childrens fluoride toothpaste, Toms of Maine Childrens Toothpaste Fluoride Free, Crest Complete Whitening Plus Cinnamon Expressions Toothpaste, Kingfisher Natural toothpaste with Fluoride, Burts Bees Kids Fruit Fusion Toothpaste With Fluoride, Contain fluoride. This wasnt what I was looking for, but it filled a niche in my household regardless. 3-Ounce, packaging may vary, Desert Essence Tea Tree Oil Toothpaste - Mint - 6.25 Ounce - Refreshing Taste - Deep Cleans Teeth & Gums - Helps Fight Plaque - Sea Salt - Pure Essential Oil - Baking Soda - Promotes Healthy Mouth, Sensodyne Pronamel Intensive Enamel Repair Toothpaste for Sensitive Teeth, to Reharden and Strengthen Enamel, Extra Fresh - 3.4 Ounces (Pack of 3), Davids Nano Hydroxyapatite Natural Toothpaste, Sensitive, Whitening, Enamel Health, Fluoride Free, SLS Free, Peppermint, 5.25 oz Metal Tube, Tube Roller Included, Tom's of Maine ADA Approved Fluoride Children's Toothpaste, Natural Toothpaste, Dye Free, No Artificial Preservatives, Silly Strawberry, 5.1 oz. Feminism 101: Objectification & Sexualization vs. The toothpaste didnt foam up and was very thin. I found an answer to this! If you want a fluoridated toothpaste, you care about science and therefore wouldnt want activated charcoal to render the fluoride useless. The flavor was very faint and nearly undetectable. You can find it anywhere. Ive Evernoted your post so I can refer back to it when my current toothpaste runs out. You may have heard them at Skepticon, the American Atheists National Convention, the Huffington Post Live, and Have Your Say on the BBC World Service or read about them in the New York Times. My spouse has used Sensodyne for years. specifically for travel use, so I dont have to worry about liquids or about bursting a tube in my bag. Shop products from small business brands sold in Amazons store. Its not the only toothpaste out there that has re-mineralizing ingredients, although its the only one Ive found in non-mint flavors; Apagard and Linhart both have similar active ingredient claims and are both described by reviewers as less harshly minty than other toothpastes. I hate mint- and also loathe the kids flavors I get stuck with at the dentist. Sadly no. Do you have any non-mint mouthwash recommendations? That defeats the purpose for me. Some people can swill citrus and never floss and still have great teeth, while others will always have issues regardless of meticulous dental hygiene practices. Setting aside flavor, its as effective as it is odd. The list should include Twice as its both cruelty-free and vegan. Contains zinc citrate helps to prevent tartar build up reducing effects on gums. Oregano also would burn for us if you ate it similarly prepared. I do a happy dance when fennel is available in my produce box. You may also want to use a fluoride rinse (see below) since the childrens stuff has less fluoride. Thanks so much for posting this, I am 20 and I have been reduced to using mostly kids toothpaste all my life because for some reason even the smell of mint can make me nauseous, and tasting mint-heavy flavors is a trigger for my migraines (honestly, maybe Im just strongly averse or allergic, but I cant stand it). I want to avoid supporting their anti-scientific stance against what is actually a very beneficial additive. If you like fennel, you will like it. Sam Harris: Misogynistic or #EstrogenVibe Entrepreneur? If you really want to try it, Ill mail what I have left to you (4 oz minus a couples of little dabs). They are normally more expensive than fluoride, but there is lots of evidence supporting their effectiveness. Colgate Active Lemon & Salt Healthy White Toothpaste, There was a luxe Japanese brand for a minute that sold no fewer than 28 fancy varieties, You definitely want to use the amount you actually need rather than what looks good in ads, Crest Complete Whitening Plus Cinnamon Expressions. Juicy fruit notes like peach, pineapple, mango, cranberry, and watermelon. Contact the authors individually for further information. I cant really comment on the remineralizing claims yet. Thought its not the cheapest, you can buy a small size to try it first and cancel the subscription if you dont like it. Related, but slightly off topic question: did you find any fluorinated toothpaste tablets, during your search? Calcium phosphates (such as hydroxyapatite) help reharden the tooth surface in a similar way to fluoride. As far as I know, you can only get it online. Kingfisher is also listed as fully vegan on their site. Unfortunately, I just went to reorder, and found they have effectively shut down their toothpaste business once COVID hit last year. Never bothered with mouthwash as it all seems to be minty. I almost cried in the grocery store today trying to find one on the shelf. As a general recommendation, mainstream brands sometimes will issue a toothpaste intended to be used at night. Why would I ever want my mouth to taste like it? Heres the tl;dr list of not-overly-minty fluoridated toothpastes that I recommend. I grew up chewing on fennel seeds after meals to freshen my breath and aid in digestion. Note: If you are concerned about the vegan and cruelty-free status of toothpaste, see Ethical Elephant for a list of brands. I hate the activated charcoal trend. There are spices like chai, neroli, lemongrass, neem, myrrh, anise, fennel, clove, ginger, nutmeg, and cardamom. Available as unflavoured or cinnamon flavoured. Keep in mind that none of these options is ever going to be as cost-effective as just getting whatever Costco has or whatevers on sale with a coupon. I get a ton of ads for them, and I kind of want to no longer be beholden to toothpaste tube waste, but I want the fluorine. Theres at least one Korean Beauty toothpaste brand with some intriguing fluoridated flavors. Your recently viewed items and featured recommendations, Select the department you want to search in, Tom's of Maine Whole Care Natural Toothpaste with Fluoride, Spearmint, 4 oz. Im an insomniac so I feel you. Notify me of follow-up comments by email. That said, Im going to try some of the suggestions on your list. Apparently they cant get FDA approval for them. Thank you SO MUCH. Will probably stick to basic kids toothpastes until I find something I really like. From early evening on, I cant go near anything that might deter from sleepiness unless I want to stay awake all night. Thank you for posting the article! And my teeth really do feel cleaner after using it than any traditional fluoride toothpaste Ive ever used. I feel really bad for the person in the reviews who got it because it has fluoride and she doesnt have fluoride in her water source(!). Sensitive tooth formulas tend to be gentler rather than burn. Who wants this? Toms adult version of the orange mango was by far the best toothpaste! I had stumbled into that strangely small yet oh-so-adult decision about personal oral care during what turned out to be a relatively narrow window. Activated charcoal is too abrasive to be very good for your teeth, isnt that good of a whitener in the first place, and might even render the fluoride inactive that is, if your trendy toothpaste even has fluoride in it to begin with. I purchased it online, as no retailer near me had it. You know, the ones that come in all those great flavors. They sound as fancy and awesome as can be. Its your standard toothpaste in both formulation and feel, just lemon-forward instead of mint. If your teeth are more prone to issues than mine, and/or you havent/dont go to the dentist as much as I do, you probably need more out of your toothpaste and other oral care products than I do. Hubby hates mint, and I have a daughter who is allergic! A repeat recommendation I got was for Toms of Maine Outrageous Orange Mango. So, I absolutely had to try Kingfisher Fennel Toothpaste even though Id already long published this post. They go by names like nighttime, bedtime, twilight, after dark, or evening. Im so glad to know Im not alone in this pursuit. 3-Pack (Packaging May Vary), Supersmile Professional Whitening Toothpaste with Fluoride - Powerful Whitening without Sensitivity - Safe and Effective on Dental Restorations (Mandarin Mint, 4.2 Oz), Himalaya Botanique Complete Care Whitening Toothpaste, Simply Mint, for a Clean Mouth, Whiter Teeth and Fresh Breath, 5.29 oz, 2 Pack, WITH MY Lemonade Toothpaste 3.5oz-Dentist Developed, EWG Verified, Cruelty-Free & Vegan, PETA and Vegan Society Registered, give Back, Tom's of Maine Fluoride-Free Antiplaque & Whitening Natural Toothpaste, Fennel, 5.5 oz. Some even come in pellet or tab form, which is less messy and involves less packaging than tubes. *seriously, bubble fruit? This has been my white whale since 2017 as well. It comes to about $12 a tube when shipped to the US. I got it because I was sick of toothpaste burning me and not for anti fluoride woo reasons. But dang is some of this stuff expensive. They make flouridated and non-flouridated (UGH) versions of their toothpastes, so if youre buying it, be sure you get the right kind. Eli is a speaker and panelist on a range of diverse topics including feminism, race, LGBT issues, the challenges of deconversion, Islam, non-monogamy, strategies for inclusivity, and the various intersections of the above. Nothing about including mint in toothpaste actually makes teeth more clean! This list does seem like a very good resource, so Ive bookmarked it to check some things out. The year I was first allowed to decide what kind of toothpaste I wanted to use all by myself and all for myself was 2007. Suitable for a wide range of medical conditions. Here it is, gentlepersons. It tastes strange, starting with not much of anything but ending with a gritty aftertaste of cheap matcha tea dregs mixed with charcoal. Saying I love the taste of fennel is a complete understatement. Sorry, your blog cannot share posts by email. The downside is that theyre often really, really sweet and come in flavors I loathe, like bubblegum or generic fake-tasting fruit. Twice is explicitly anti-pseudoscience (!) All content is copyright the authors except where otherwise noted. Theres a reason I refuse to link to any exclusively fluoride-free brands (and am annoyed about Toms of Maine and Hello and Kingfisher). Will see what the dentist says. Thanks to a combination of genetics, electric brushing, luck, and excellent childhood dental care, I have good teeth. Thanks for alerting me to Twice. Who was it made for? He does like it so far, so I tried it. Of the big brands, Ive found Crest Original to be less minty. I picked some up (watermelon flavored!) Certain oral conditions may make mint toothpaste uncomfortable in the mouth, for example: Head and neck cancer patients after radiotherapy. It foams up some, though not as much as a standard toothpaste. Bubble Gum Blowout, Lumineux Teeth Whitening Toothpaste - Natural & Enamel Safe for Sensitive & Whiter Teeth - Certified Non-Toxic, Fluoride Free, No Alcohol, Artificial Colors, SLS Free & Dentist Formulated, Tom's of Maine ADA Approved Fluoride Children's Toothpaste, Natural Toothpaste, Dye Free, No Artificial Preservatives, Outrageous Orange Mango, 5.1 oz. A mint-free, not-too-sweet kids toothpaste: Transitional kids toothpastes, intended to take older kids from the sweet flavors of childhood to the harsh mint of the grown-up world. As an adult, Ive developed a real taste for fresh fennel bulb and fennel fronds in my food and as DIY tisane. The Brazilian lime flavor is amazing. I dont give up easily, though. The rinse felt about a quarter as minty as regular Listerine, starting off very gentle and mild then peaking about ten minutes after I spat it out. My only complaint is that Id likely eventually get tired of it, since vanilla and lavender are a little boring as far as flavors go. Bonabits comes in Royal Lemon Herb, Noble Peach Blossom, and Velvet Rose Apple Balm. Im so happy to help. Thanks! I found out because Facebook and Instagram keep showing me ads for bougie dental products.